Skip to main content

FDA-Cleared TreatmentsCovered by Most InsurancePhysician-Led Care

Is It Strange to Want a Second Opinion in Psychiatry?

No. A second opinion is common and routine when a diagnosis does not fit, many medications have helped little, or a major treatment is recommended. It is a full evaluation with records and questionnaires. No referral is needed in Colorado. TMS Therapy Centers Colorado offers second-opinion evaluations in person or by video statewide.

Watch: Second Opinions in Psychiatry: When They Make Sense and What They Involve

Second Opinions in Psychiatry: When They Make Sense and What They Involve

From the TMS Therapy Centers Colorado video series. Educational only; not medical advice.

Is it strange to want a second opinion in psychiatry? It is more common than people assume and far less awkward than they fear. In other areas of medicine, a second look before a major decision is routine, and mental health care is no different. For people in Denver and across Colorado, a second opinion can be arranged without a referral and often by video. This article explains when a second opinion makes sense, what the evaluation involves, and what it can and cannot accomplish.

When a second opinion makes sense

There are several moments when a second opinion is particularly worth considering.

The diagnosis does not quite fit

One is when a diagnosis does not quite fit the lived experience. A person may have been treated for depression for years without lasting benefit and wonder whether something is being missed, such as bipolar disorder, ADHD, a thyroid issue, or something else. If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or go to the nearest emergency room.

Raising the question does not mean the current diagnosis is wrong. It means the person wants to be sure, which is a reasonable thing to want.

A long series of medications has produced little

Another is when a long series of medications has produced little, and the person wants to know whether options such as TMS, SPRAVATO, or ketamine therapy have been considered. Our page on treatment-resistant depression explains why that history matters and what options often come next.

A significant treatment has been recommended

A third is when a treatment has been recommended that feels significant, and the person simply wants a second psychiatrist to confirm it is the right decision before committing. That is a sensible impulse for any major medical decision.

What a second opinion evaluation looks like

A second opinion evaluation looks like any psychiatric evaluation. It includes:

  • A full history
  • A review of records and previous medications
  • Standardized questionnaires
  • A conversation about what has and has not worked

Our article on what a psychiatric evaluation is walks through each part. A second opinion simply applies that process with a fresh set of eyes.

What to bring

Bringing records from the current provider helps, including a list of medications with doses and dates, but it is not required. The psychiatrist can work from the person's own account. A short written timeline of past treatments is useful if one is available, and the clinic can request records with permission.

What a second psychiatrist offers

What the second psychiatrist offers is a fresh set of eyes and, often, a different range of treatments to draw on. A practice that offers TMS, SPRAVATO, ketamine therapy, and medication management can look at the whole map of options, not only the ones available in a medication-only practice.

Outcomes vary. Sometimes the second opinion confirms the current plan, which is valuable because it replaces doubt with confidence. Sometimes it identifies a missed diagnosis or a treatment path the person had never been offered. Either result is useful.

A second opinion is not a verdict on your current provider

A second opinion does not require leaving the current provider, and many psychiatrists welcome it. A good one will say so. The goal is information, and the person can choose how to use it, whether that means staying with the current plan, adding a treatment, or changing providers.

How to raise it with your current provider

Many people worry about how to bring it up. It helps to be plain: "I would like another psychiatrist to review my situation before I decide." Most clinicians have heard this before. If a provider reacts defensively, that is information too, but most respond with support and offer to share records.

Things a second opinion cannot do

It is worth keeping expectations realistic. A second opinion carries no assurance of a different answer. It does not undo past treatment. And it works well when the person gives a full and candid history, including substance use and past reactions to medications. It can, however, give clarity about what to do next, which is often what people want most.

Comparing the options that emerge

If a second opinion points toward a procedure or a medication change, it helps to ask how the options compare. Our article on TMS pros and cons is one example of the kind of balanced comparison worth reading before deciding.

No referral required

In Colorado, no referral is needed to arrange a second opinion. A person can contact a psychiatric clinic directly and request an evaluation. Benefits are verified first so there are no surprises about coverage.

Questions to ask the second psychiatrist

A second opinion is more useful when the person arrives with specific questions. Examples include:

  • Do you agree with the current diagnosis, and why or why not?
  • Are there other conditions that could explain what I am experiencing?
  • Which treatments have I not yet tried that might be appropriate?
  • What would you recommend as a first step, and what would the next step be?
  • How would you measure whether a change is working?

These questions invite the psychiatrist to explain reasoning, not just offer a conclusion. A clear explanation is part of what makes a second opinion worth having.

How care works at TMS Therapy Centers Colorado

TMS Therapy Centers Colorado is a physician-led clinic founded by William Kromka, MD, a board-certified psychiatrist. Second opinion evaluations are available in person or by private video from anywhere in Colorado, with TMS, SPRAVATO, ketamine therapy, and medication management within the same physician-led team. Most major insurance plans are accepted, and benefits are verified before treatment begins. To begin, call 720-500-7873.

A: Common moments include when a diagnosis does not fit your experience, when many medications have helped little and you want to know whether TMS, SPRAVATO, or ketamine therapy were considered, or when a significant treatment has been recommended and you want confirmation before committing.